Vietnam Business Law

View Original

Is “business transfer” a “share transfer”, “project transfer” or “assets transfer”?

A business transfer can generally understood as the transfer of, among other things, the assets, employees, contracts, clients and goodwill associated with a particular business. However, “business transfer” is not clear legal concept under Vietnamese law. In Vietnam, when one mentions "business transfer", it is not clear whether it refers to the transfer of (1) shares of the company that runs such business or (2) the assets and other components that constitute such business.

In case of (1), then a business transfer should probably better called as a share transfer transaction. In case of (2), commercially, a business transfer could be structured as the transfer of an “investment project” (see earlier post here) as provided under Article 66 of Decree 108/2006. However, there is no clear procedures under Decree 108 for a "project transfer" transaction which does not involve the transfer of shares of the project company. In particular,

  • Article 66.2 of Decree 108 provides that in the case of assignment of a project of an economic organization not associated with the termination of operation of the assigning economic organization, the assignment of the project will comply with the conditions and procedures for assignment of capital;
  • Article 66.3 of Decree 108 provides that in the case of assignment of a project of an economic organization associated with the termination of operation of the assigning economic organization, the assignment of the project shall comply with the conditions and procedures for merger with or acquisition of an enterprise;
  • Article 66.4 of Decree 108 provides that in the case of assignment of an investment project associated with the termination of operation of the assigning organization and the assignee establishing an economic organization to continue implementation of the project, the investment procedures stipulated by this Decree must be carried out.

A “project transfer”, which is not a share transfer, is not associated with the termination of the assigning organization so Articles 66.3 and 66.4 of Decree 108 are not applicable. However, Article 66.2 of Decree 108 requires a transfer of project not associated with the termination of the assigning organization to follow procedures for assignment of capital. It is not clear how a project transfer by way of selling assets could comply with the procedures for assignment of capital.

As such, in case of (2), to avoid all the complications of a project transfer regulations, the parties can just structure a business transfer as a transfer of assets and other components of the transferred business.