How Agreements On ROFO, ROFR, Tag Along And Drag Along Could Work In A Multiple Member Limited Liability Company In Vietnam?

In a shareholder agreement (or joint venture agreement) between members of a multiple member limited liability companies (Multiple LLC), the members often agree on various transfer restrictions such as right of first offer (ROFO), right of first refusal (ROFR), tag along or drag along rights. These transfers are intended for the parties to control the ownership structure of the Multiple LLC and their exit from the Multiple LLC. However, implementing such agreements on transfer restriction may be inconsistent with the statutory transfer restrictions provided in Article 52 of the Enterprise Law 2020. Therefore, a shareholder agreement relating to a Multiple LLC should have specific provision to resolve such inconsistencies.

The table below sets out the potential inconsistencies between agreements on ROFO, ROFR, Tag Along and Drag Along and the transfer procedures under Article 52 of the Enterprise Law 2020.

Read MoreInfo
Comment
Written by Nguyen Quang Vu On In ,

Status Of Partially Secured Creditors Under Law On Bankruptcy 2014

Under the Law on Bankruptcy 2014, creditors (chủ nợ) of a bankrupt enterprise include unsecured creditors, partially secured creditors (chủ nợ có bảo đảm một phần) and secured creditors (chủ nợ có bảo đảm). While it is not entirely clear, it appears that partially secured creditors are considered as a separate class of creditors and have their own rights during a bankruptcy proceeding.

Under the Law on Bankruptcy 2014,

  • a secured creditor is defined as a creditor having the right to require the relevant bankrupt enterprise to perform an obligation to repay a secured debt with the assets of the enterprise or a third party; and

  • a partially secured creditor is defined as a creditor having the right to require the relevant bankrupt enterprise to perform an obligation to repay a secured debt with the assets of the enterprise or a third party “where the value of such assets is less than that debt”.

The definition of a secured creditor does not clearly refer to “fully secured creditors” since it does not require the value of the secured assets is equal or more than the debt owed to a secured creditor. Accordingly, technically, the term “secured creditor” could cover both partially secured creditor and fully secured creditor. That said, a more in-depth reading of the Bankruptcy Law 2014 suggests that partially secured creditors are treated as a separate class of creditors. However, it is not clear whether this distinction is created by design or by chance by the draftsman of the Bankruptcy Law 2014.

Read MoreInfo
Comment
Written by Nguyen Quang Vu On In ,

Validity of Board Resignations in Vietnamese Joint Stock Companies

From January 2021, under the Enterprise Law 2020, if a member of the board of directors (the Board) hands in his/her letter of resignation to resign as a Board member in a joint stock company (JSC), he/she may not cease to be a Board Member until approved so by the General Meeting of Shareholders (GMS) of the relevant JSC. To mitigate the potential issues arising from this provision, a JSC may consider providing that the GMS must dismiss a Board member when he/she tenders his/her resignation. In addition, the resigning Board Member should give authorisation to another appropriate person until he/she is officially dismissed.

Read MoreInfo
Comment
Written by Nguyen Quang Vu On In

Shareholder Rights During The First 90 Days Of Incorporation Of A Joint Stock Company

After incorporating a joint stock company (JSC), the founding shareholders of the JSC will typically have 90 days from the issuance of the enterprise registration certificate (Capital Contribution Period) to pay for the shares they have subscribed as at the incorporation of the JSC (Subscription Shares). Under the Enterprise Law 2020, it is reasonable to consider that during the Capital Contribution Period, the founding shareholders who have not paid for the Subscription Shares in full would have all the shareholders rights including rights to transfer the Shares which have not been paid up. However, the drafting of the Enterprise Law 2020 could give rise to the position that during the Capital Contribution Period shareholder rights, the founding shareholders have only the voting right.

Read MoreInfo
Comment
Written by Nguyen Quang Vu On In